Passive vs. Tactical Investing
Passive Investing
Passive investing means putting money into a mix of investments and leaving it mostly untouched, rather than frequently buying and selling. The goal isn't to beat the market — it's to match its performance over time.
This approach typically involves choosing a mix of investments upfront, based on a person's goals and how much risk they're comfortable with, and then holding onto that mix for the long term. Adjustments are infrequent, and they're usually made to bring the account back to its original target mix rather than to react to what the market is doing that week or month.
- Typically, lower costs, since there's less buying and selling involved
- A consistent approach that doesn't change based on short-term market swings
- Less time-intensive to manage, since it doesn't require constant monitoring
- The account still moves up and down with the market — passive investing doesn't protect against market losses
- Tends to work best for people with a long-time horizon who are comfortable riding out market ups and downs
Tactical Investing
Tactical investing means actively adjusting a portfolio based on current market conditions, rather than leaving it alone. Changes are made when conditions call for it, with the intent of managing risk and responding to opportunities as they come up.
This approach requires ongoing attention. Someone managing a tactical portfolio is regularly reviewing what's happening in the market and adjusting — which could mean moving money into or out of certain investments, adjusting how much risk the portfolio is carrying, or responding to specific events affecting the market.
- More hands-on and actively managed than a passive approach
- Intended to help manage risk and respond to changing conditions — though there's no guarantee it will outperform a passive approach in any given period
- Requires more ongoing attention and adjustments than a passive approach
- Generally, involves more monitoring and trading activity, which can mean higher costs than a passive approach
Passive vs. Tactical: The Key Differences
The biggest difference between the two comes down to how involved the management is, and what each approach is trying to accomplish.
| Passive | Tactical |
Management style | Set an allocation and hold it | Actively adjusted over time |
Goal | Match the market's performance | Manage risk and respond to conditions |
How often it changes | Rarely — mainly to rebalance | Regularly, based on market conditions |
Typical costs | Generally lower | Generally higher |
Attention required | Minimal ongoing monitoring | Ongoing review and adjustment |
Market risk | Fully exposed to market swings | Exposed to market risk and the risk that adjustments made are wrong |
Best suited for | Long time horizon, comfortable with volatility and the market ups and downs | Investors wanting a more actively managed approach with managing risk |
Neither approach eliminates risk. Passive accounts are fully exposed to market swings, since they don't adjust in response to conditions. Tactical accounts take on a different kind of risk — the risk that the adjustments made don't turn out to be the right call. Which approach fits best depends on a person's goals, how involved they want their investments to be, and how much risk they're comfortable with.
